When a child is born, or any time after birth, parents can choose to sign an Affidavit of Parentage (AOP) that legally establishes the father of the child and allows for information about the father to be added to the birth certificate. This is common in cases where parents aren’t married (as a husband would immediately be assumed to be the father under Michigan law). What if there’s a mistake that could impact custody and parenting time?
In this case, Michigan law allows for revocation of paternity, by which a legally established father that is not the biological father of a child can be stripped of his paternity and parenting rights. Of course, this is only applicable under certain circumstances, as a recent case in Michigan proves. What transpired in Kalin v. Fleming? How does it relate to revocation of paternity and mistake of fact, and what do unmarried parents need to know?
Kalin v. Fleming
The day after Fleming (the mother) gave birth to her child, she and Kalin signed an AOP stating that he was the father. Although Fleming later admitted the paternity was uncertain, she never told Kalin, allowing him to believe he was the father. When the couple later separated, Fleming denied Kalin parenting time and told him he was not the father, to which he responded with action in Family Court to get custody, parenting time, and child support.
Fleming then filed a motion for extension that would allow her to set aside the AOP under the rules outlined in the Revocation of Paternity Act. She claimed that a mistake of fact allowed for the revocation of paternity.
Revocation of Paternity
There are specific rules related to revocation of paternity. First and foremost, a motion for revocation of paternity must be filed within 1 year of the date the AOP was signed, or within 3 years of the child’s birth, whichever comes later. In the case of Kalin v. Fleming, both of these deadlines had passed. That said, the filing time may be extended in cases involving:
According to Fleming, the mistake of fact in this case was that Kalin didn’t know he was the father of the child, and this fact therefor gave her grounds to seek an extension for revocation of paternity. Kalin countered Fleming’s motion, saying that Fleming had no legal grounds to set aside the AOP.
The court ruled in Fleming’s favor initially, but a court of appeals reversed the decision, stating that while there was a mistake of fact on Kalin’s part, it did not meet the criteria for the person filing the motion for extension (Fleming) to prove that one of the five exceptions prevented her from timely action in revoking the AOP. After all, she knew that Kalin was not the father long before the deadline to file for revocation of paternity.
This case should serve as a lesson for unmarried parents in Michigan relying on an AOP to establish parental rights. Without further means to establish paternity (such as a blood test), there’s a danger of revocation of paternity. This is why it’s best to contact a qualified attorney from The Gucciardo Law Firm at 248-723-5190 if you’re an unmarried parent and/or paternity is in question.
Too much information?
We focus exclusively on family law matters so we are always available to answer your questions and help.
Renee and her team have represented me in family law at the highest level since 2015. I have had the opportunity to observe her and her entire team in action for many years. The Gucciardo law firm have performed a variety of legal tasks for me including evidentiary hearings, motion paperwork and general administrative support. I can assert without reservation that she is the best attorney I have employed or observed. This is a significant statement because I have had the unfortunate experience to employ 5 other attorneys in the same time period for different family law applications/issues. I have employed attorneys that were hip, fast talkers but unorganized and unproductive. I have employed expensive attorneys that have gouged me and not performed. I have employed attorneys that are organized and honest but not aggressive. I have employed cheap attorneys that were lazy. I know bad, decent and awesome. Renee is awesome. She and her team are responsive, experienced, organized, creative, conscientious, productive and honest. Renee's support staff of experts are just that and are profoundly capable. Sick of your legal team not calling you back? That won't happen with Gucciardo. Concerned you won't get value for your money? That won't happen with Gucciardo. Frustrated with paying and not seeing results? Not a chance with Renee. Don't what to have the feeling that your legal team does not have your back? Won't happen with Renee. Attorneys are expensive but if you get the value, you won't resent them. I resent all my other attorneys except Renee and her team. She won big for me and almost killed herself in the process. She was not afraid to bring up risky issues and call out other professionals for improper behavior. Renee did this because it was the correct thing to do and because she worked for ME! Renee is a sweetheart until it is time to be aggressive. Renee and her team are always prepared and I enjoy a teamwork feeling with her team that most lawyers won't offer because most lawyers are narcissists. Renee is confident and accomplished but not a narcissist. Renee is not afraid to perform menial legal tasks that other attorneys dish off to their subordinates. Renee often performs these "menial tasks" because she is goal oriented and not afraid of hard work. The next day Renee is in front of the courtroom arguing for you in a fashion that is similar to some Hollywood movie- except this is real! We can influence our luck in life by surrounding ourselves with good people. The Gucciardo law firm ARE good people. This review too good to be true? Call the Gucciardo Law firm, ask them to get us in touch with each other and hear it from my lips. Best regards, John
I am forever thankful to you! The court has definitely taught me to be stronger. I remember you as a strong attorney who faced the judge who almost took the kids away. I can't imagine if that happened in that courtroom. You are my heroine!
Hey Renee Just wanted to say Happy Birthday. But also -- as my daughter Liz turns 18 tomorrow -- I wanted to say thank you for all of your hard work on the case involving Liz. You fought for Sue and I every step of the way and we never, ever lost a battle with you at our side. While going through essentially two custody battles to get Liz living with us, you made it look easy and you won every round for us with ease. Sue and I have recommended you to so many people that we've lost count. I think Sue will agree with me that you are honestly the best family attorney that anyone could ever hire. We'll both continue recommending you to anyone in need if an all-star. You've been there to read my 5,000-word, long-winded emails, you've been there at every court date, you always were quick to answer every call and showed compassion to Sue and I all the time. Thank you for believing in us and giving us the confidence over the years in my daughter's case, especially when Liz's mother was making life very difficult for us. Liz started at Macomb Community College today and she's doing well. She's working and growing up into a beautiful, mature young lady. I can't thank you enough for being responsible for getting Liz to live with us full time. Sue and I truly believe that Liz living with us saved her from living an enormously difficult life with her mother (Liz now has not seen her mom in over 3 years). We've had a long relationship for 10 years as our friend! Stay in touch on Facebook and I wish you the greatest success in your practice and with your family. Take care and all the best to you!
Tom and Sue Varcie